Made in India, Claimed by the West: When Haute Couture Meets Legal Vacuum
[By Inika Dular] The author is a student of Rajiv Gandhi National University of Law, Punjab Why the controversy? The recently released Kolhapuri chappal version by Prada, a design steeped in cultural history in Maharashtra, truly made waves, not for beauty but for a price tag of INR 1.2 lakh without meaningful acknowledgement of its Indian roots. Very shortly after, Dior showcased a USD 200,000 overcoat with mukaish embroidery, the metallic thread technique that has been perfected for centuries by artisans in Lucknow. This coat was lauded by fashion critics and jeered at by Indian designers and craft advocates. There was, however, little mention of Indian craftsmen who developed the technique in the marketing materials. The brand had organised a show in Mumbai in 2023, but crediting a country is not the same as crediting a community. The IP Law Blind Spot Intellectual Property (IP) law, as designed, protects novelty and individual authorship. Copyright guards original artistic work and economic value; design law protects industrial designs for a limited duration; and trademarks ensure brand identity. But what happens when the author is a community, the novelty is centuries old, and the economic value is repackaged by someone else? The Kolhapuri chappal, for instance, received a Geographical Indication (GI) tag in 2019, a tool meant to protect products rooted in place and tradition, like Champagne or Darjeeling tea. Yet, GIs only restrict unauthorised use within the jurisdiction of registration, unless India signs reciprocal protection agreements. Prada, headquartered in Italy, is not bound by the Indian GI regime, nor does Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) (the WTO’s IP framework) enforce these protections meaningfully across borders. The ineffectiveness of the existing international arrangements becomes apparent when one observes the treatment of GI under the TRIPS Agreement. Article 22 of TRIPS caters only to basic protection for GIs in all products, requiring Member States to stop the use of a GI that misleads the public or amounts to unfair competition. At the same time, enhanced protection is provided for in Article 23 for only wines and spirits. Under this two-tier system, European alcoholic beverages enjoy a higher degree of protection than the handicrafts of African and many other developing countries. Articles 22 and 23 require member countries to refuse or invalidate trademark registrations containing false geographical indications, but it is for wines and spirits alone that such protection stands, regardless of whether the public is being misled. Indian courts have had to fight these issues through landmark decisions revealing the imbalance in IP protection. In Scotch Whisky Association v. Pravara Sahakari Shakkara Karkhana, the Bombay High Court recognized GI protection for Scotch whisky without any Indian registration, thereby indicating how international brands can rely on their reputation for protection. This recognition was, however, not extended reciprocally to Indian traditional crafts in foreign jurisdictions, where local artisans do not have the resources or legal standing to pursue this sort of protection. The case law reveals a disturbing tendency: the courts in India have tended to exhibit sympathy toward foreign GIs for matters of international reputation and consumer recognition, whereas hardly ever do Indian traditional crafts stand for such recognition abroad. That judicial discrimination is indeed but a superficial lineal manifestation of deeper, embedded structural inequities afflicting the global IP structure; that is to say, consumers of a market are made aware through marketing expenditures by well-gelded established brands; such consumer awareness is accepted by courts as an interest worthy of protection, and such an interest can be denied to traditional artisans aiming at establishing a market from within their informal networks. What Dior Gets to Do, Mukaish Workers Can’t Let us go back to the Mukaish overcoat again. This technique, which employs twisting micro-thin metallic wires into fabric patterns, goes way back to the Mughal era and is still kept alive by the underpaid artisans working in the narrow alleys of Lucknow. Contrary to this electrifying history, a Dior product, whose price is equal to what these artisans can earn in a lifetime, never made any mention of these craftsmen, nor did they share any royalties or enter into any form of collaboration. If an Indian label tried to reverse-engineer the Dior coat, and managed to get hold of its look and feel, it could face suits for design infringement, DMCA takedowns, and brand dilution claims. But there is no reciprocal right available to these craftsmen. Presently, the IP law setup can perhaps be described by the nomenclature: ‘lawful cultural piracy.’ The Indian Designs Act, 2000, ostensibly protects industrial design but systematically excludes traditional crafts. Section 2(d) defines design through the lens of industrial manufacture and does not cater to the domain of community craftsmanship, wherein designs are generated on an organic basis through mutational changes across generations. Section 4 prescribes that the design be new, but this demands an impossible standard for an ancient technique like that of mukaish work, and Section 11 boldly offers just 10 years of protection, which is terribly short for traditional designs that have been molded by generations of cultural expression. The enforcement asymmetry finds manifestation in the outcome of litigation. Indian courts have favoured Western luxury brands over Indian manufacturers. The Delhi High Court, in the case of Louis Vuitton v. Haute24.com, granted a permanent injunction against and awarded damages to the plaintiffs against Indian defendants. In Louis Vuitton Malletier v. Futuretimes Technology India Private Limited, the Court awarded ₹20 lakh damages in favour of the French luxury house for trademark infringement. These cases reveal how, within a matter of months, the established brands get ex parte interim injunctions, while the traditional artisans have none at their disposal. In contrast, traditional artisans face an evidentiary problem beyond the reach of the legal regime. How does one prove ownership of techniques passed down through generations without written records? The individual proprietary focus of Section 5 of the Indian Designs Act actually works against traditional handicrafts of a collective nature, effectively rendering entire communities legally invisible
Made in India, Claimed by the West: When Haute Couture Meets Legal Vacuum Read More »









