Recalling the witness – Understanding the phenomenon of multiple cross examinations in the context of arbitration
[ Gibran Naushad & Susanah Naushad ] Gibran Naushad is an Associate at S&R Associates, New Delhi and Susanah Naushad is an Associate at Khaitan & Co., New Delhi. Introduction It is often said that cross-examinations can make or break a trial, a testimony to the importance of the process in the overall scheme of adjudication. There are, however, different ways in which one could approach cross-examination, depending on the nature of the case and the eventual result desired. Given the importance of cross-examinations in trial, situations are bound to arise where a party might want to conduct such examination again owing to its dissatisfaction with the previous cross-examination, amongst other factors. Such multiple cross-examinations are, however, a tricky terrain, and it is not in all cases that such repetition would be allowed. This is particularly true in the context of arbitrations, where the parties would have to primarily depend on the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 to carry out such a process. The authors, through this post, try and explain the practical dimensions of cross examination and the options available to parties in case they are dissatisfied with a cross-examination already conducted. Case laws dealing with the subject would be looked at and an attempt would be made to understand the restrictions imposed on the parties to correct their mistakes or lapses by repeating a process that is germane to any trial. Understanding The Practice Of Cross-Examination Cross examination is one of the most vital constituents of trial. It becomes highly important to question the adversary on crucial facts relating to the matter to establish their falsehood or truthfulness, thereby establishing the credibility of such facts and claims to be taken up during the final arguments in the matter. There is no straightjacket formula for conducting cross-examination. The strategy and method could differ with different counsels. Additionally, the facts and circumstances of different cases along with the eventual result sought to be achieved would require different approaches to be adopted. Certain counsels prefer to attack the witnesses on each and every fact, thereby posing straight questions to such witnesses and subsequently changing the orientation of such questions with each answer so as to direct the witness to their preferred answer. This ensures that the inability of the witnesses to answer correctly and comfortably the questions posed to them on certain facts and claims could be used against them at the time of making the final arguments in the matter. The other approach, however, is a more subtle approach wherein instead of questions, the counsel puts across certain suggestions which follow questions. The suggestions are meant to point towards the insufficiency in the answers to the questions. An example of such a suggestion could be – ‘I put it to you that you are lying about the illegal termination of the contract with Party X’. The aim behind putting such suggestions is to create an adverse inference against the party at the time of final arguments. Therefore, while the former approach is a head-on approach where the answers themselves bring out the adverse inference, the latter approach is a more nuanced approach where the counsel realizes that it would not be possible to extract such answers and it would be better to suggest adverse inferences. In view of the fact that there is no fixed approach for conducting cross-examinations, there is a possibility that post the completion of the cross-examination; a party might feel that it wants to cross-examine its adversary again. The reasons for this could vary, from strategic lapses by the counsel to new facts coming on record which merit putting up the person on stand yet again. However, conducting such cross-examination for the second time is an uncertain proposition, particularly in the context of arbitration, and such strategy might not fly past the arbitrator in most cases. The Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (the “Act”) does not contain specific provisions for examination of the witnesses. However, Section 19 of the Act does stipulate that the parties are free to choose a procedure for the conduct of the arbitral proceedings.[1] Additionally, in case such procedure has not been agreed upon by the parties, the arbitral tribunal could conduct the proceedings in the manner it deems appropriate.[2] The Act stipulates that the arbitral tribunal would not be bound by the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (the “Code”).[3]However, the Bombay High Court decision of Maharashtra State Electricity Board v. Datar Switchgear Limited[4] becomes important in this context. The Bombay High Court, while dealing with Section 19(1) of the Act clearly stated that Section 19(1) of the Act contained words of amplitude and not of restriction.[5] Therefore, though the arbitral tribunal is not bound by the Code, it could draw sustenance from the fundamental principles underlying the Code.[6] Order XVIII Rule 17 is one such provision from where sustenance can be drawn. The provision stipulates that the Court could at any stage of the suit recall a witness who has been examined and put such questions to the witness as the Court thinks fit. Therefore, if the Court is satisfied that there are grounds that exist for the recalling of the witness, cross-examination can be conducted on such witness again. Order XVIII, Rule 17: Discretionary But Limited Scope of Recall Order XVIII, Rule 17 is clearly a provision of the Code which could be used for recalling witnesses in arbitration proceedings. Though the provision stipulates that the Court can recall the witness on its own if it feels the need to do so, the parties could also make applications to invoke this provision and request the Court for such recalling. It has been held by the Punjab and Haryana High Court in the case of Om Prakash v. Sarupa[7] that the court could not only use Order XVIII, Rule 17 of the Code to recall a witness on its own but could also use this provision on an application made by the defendants. Similar views have been held by the
